On a wintry Tallinn tram, Mr Smith sits squashed between grinning cookie trackers in a burgundy velvet suit and a navy pinstripe, while a rolled-up newspaper scribbles notes behind him and a glamorous woman in sunglasses reads a magazine over his shoulder. Yellow the canary sits on his shoulder, unimpressed. A faceless grey figure with the number 8 watches from the back.

Mr Smith vs. the Reject All Button

A cookie satire on rails. Mr Smith rejects all. They all stay. Until the lion.

DISPATCH/9 MIN READ

Listen · Read by the author

Prefer your podcast app? Spotify · Apple Podcasts · RSS

The Commuter Read

This is the short version. For the screenshots, the cookie counts and the complete references, read the full inquiry: The Reject All Button Is Lying to You →

Mr Smith Shorts

One commute. Now it makes sense.

Mr Smith is in Tallinn, Estonia, this week. Nobody knows why. Nobody asks.

Yellow came too. She’s sitting on his shoulder at a tram stop by the old town walls, feathers puffed against the cold.

“Most digital country in Europe,” says Mr Smith. “Four errands. Five minutes.”

Yellow raises one eyebrow. “Read me the list.”

“News. Dinner. Travel advice. Hot dogs.”

“Oof. Ambitious.”

Part 1 · Monday · Tram

Hand-to-Hand Combat

“Headlines first,” says Mr Smith. “Nothing stressful.”

He opens HuffPost.

Behind him, the platform quietly fills up. First, a rolled-up newspaper in a trench coat, scribbling in a notepad. That’s HuffPost itself. Then a man in a burgundy velvet suit, corkboard under his arm: faces and places, pinned up and joined with red string. Six more shortly follow. They all study the timetable suspiciously hard.

Canary note
The velvet suit and his friends are trackers: little bits of code that follow you around the web. In real life, you’d never see them. On this tram, you can. The velvet suit is LiveRamp, a big American data company. His job is matching you up, so the you on this site is the same you everywhere else. That’s what the red string is for.

The tram pulls in. Mr Smith gets on. So do all seven, and the newspaper. The velvet suit takes the seat right next to him, adjusts his cuffs, and smiles a little too widely.

Mr Smith goes back to his phone. A cookie banner. He sighs through his nose and taps Essential cookies only. (That’s HuffPost’s word for “Reject all”.)

“There,” he says. “No.”

Next stop. The doors open.

Nobody gets off.

The newspaper licks his pencil and writes something down.

“Seven,” says Yellow.

“Seven what?”

“They were on before you said anything.”

The doors start to close. One more slips through the gap sideways. No face. No name. Just the number 8 pinned to its coat.

“Who’s that?” whispers Mr Smith.

“Nobody knows. It got on after you said no.”

Mr Smith narrows his eyes. Somewhere behind them, the conspiracy cogs start to grind. The nameless one doesn’t blink. Mr Smith looks away first.

“Right. Dinner,” he says, firmly changing the subject. “The flat I’m renting has one pan.”

“One?”

“One. One-pan dinner. Done.”

A single frying pan, drawn in ink, with a wisp of steam rising from it.

He opens Epicurious, for a recipe. At the next stop, a glossy magazine in big sunglasses and red heels clicks aboard, clipboard in hand, handbag spilling cookies.

The tram lurches. She bumps him. “Oops, darling. Don’t mind me, just squeezing in next to ya.” She looks him up and down. “Ooh. Aren’t you a find.”

When he looks down, there’s a number stamped on his hand. Yellow peels a sticker off his back and holds it up between two feathers: a label. (A visitor ID, and the audience group they’ve filed him in.)

“I haven’t even said hello,” he mutters to Yellow, out of the corner of his mouth.

“You don’t need to. You’re a VIP now. Very Identifiable Person.”

A banner. Two buttons: I ACCEPT and YOUR PRIVACY CHOICES.

Mr Smith squints. “Where’s no?”

“Through there. Behind the small print.”

A long list of switches. All off. Except one.

“Audience Measurement. On. I didn’t switch that on.”

“She did,” says Yellow, tipping her beak towards the magazine.

The magazine examines her nails. “Saved you the trouble, darling.”

“Europe’s top court says a box ticked for you isn’t a yes,” Yellow adds. “She ticked it anyway.”

He switches it off and hits Reject all. Hard. Twice, to be sure.

“No. To all of you.”

The magazine purses her lips. Her nose gives a small, offended twitch.

Next stop. She heaves herself up from her perch, half-squidging Mr Smith on the way, and totters to the door on her heels. As it opens, she lifts one arm across the doorway, as if it had a boulder tied to it. On the platform, a long queue of cookies: the ones Mr Smith just said no to. Each holds up a ticket stamped NO. She checks every one, shakes her head, and they trudge off.

Then a cookie in a pinstripe suit flashes his lanyard: VIP: Legitimate interest. Her arm floats up like a feather. He strolls in, unbuttons his jacket, and sits on Mr Smith’s other side.

Nobody gets off.

A glamorous woman in big sunglasses and red heels, a glossy magazine under her arm, blocks the tram doorway with her arm, turning away a queue of cookies holding tickets stamped NO, while a cookie in a pinstripe suit flashes his lanyard and strolls past her. Mr Smith watches from his seat in dismay.
All of them. Except the VIP.

“I rejected all.”

“Two hundred and twenty-one heard you,” says Yellow.

Mr Smith’s eyes slide sideways to the pinstripe, who is busy making himself very comfortable. “And him?”

“He decided he had a good enough reason not to ask.”

The pinstripe straightens his lanyard, as if the tram couldn’t possibly run without him.

Mr Smith opens his mouth. Nothing comes out. He sinks a little lower into his scarf, one knitted row at a time, until only his eyes are showing.

Canary note
The pinstripe is Google. The legal term is “legitimate interest”: a company decides its reason is good enough, and doesn’t ask.

The doors close. Mr Smith is now squashed between the velvet suit and the pinstripe, with the magazine leaning over his shoulder, reading his screen.

Mr Smith counts on his gloved fingers. Two done. Two to go. His eyebrows lose the will to live. “Two errands down,” he says.

“And ten passengers up,” says Yellow, not ruffling a feather.

He closes the recipe and opens a fresh tab. “Travel advice,” he says, from somewhere inside his scarf. “Anything I should know about Estonia?”

“Brace yourself,” says Yellow.

GOV.UK. A banner. Two green buttons, same size, side by side.

“…That’s it? Two buttons?”

“Two buttons.”

He taps Reject. A small, polite message: you can change your mind any time.

The tram stops. The doors open. Nobody gets on. Mr Smith leans out and checks the platform. Empty. One pigeon. It isn’t interested in him.

A plump city pigeon, drawn in ink, pecking at a crumb and pointedly ignoring everyone.

“Where are they?”

“There aren’t any.”

“There’s always someone.”

“Not here. It just wrote down your no.”

Mr Smith looks almost disappointed.

“Boring, isn’t it?” says Yellow. “That’s what good looks like.”

Mr Smith reads his answer in peace. One clear page. No pop-ups. No you may also like. The velvet suit leans over for a peek. Yellow turns her head, very slowly, and stares at him until he looks away.

“That was… nice.”

“Don’t get used to it.”

“Last one,” says Mr Smith. “The most important. Does the IKEA here do the hot dogs?”

“Priorities.”

“I’d cross a sea for those hot dogs.”

“You may have to.”

A hot dog in a bun, drawn in ink, with a zigzag of mustard and a heap of crispy onions on top.

He opens IKEA. Three short lines: You are in control of your own cookies. Reject all sits right next to Accept all. Same size.

“In control,” Mr Smith snorts. “Heard that before.”

“Some of them even mean it,” says Yellow.

The tram stops. On the platform stands a flat-pack wardrobe in a blue IKEA T-shirt, Allen key in one gloved hand. It takes in the packed tram and gives a small, sorry shake of the head, the way you might at a badly assembled bookcase. Then it turns to Mr Smith, folds its hands over the Allen key, and waits. Behind it, a neat little queue of cookies stands in single file. Nobody pushes. Nobody even leans.

Mr Smith stares at it. It smiles back, politely. The doors stay open.

Yellow gives his ear a sharp little peck. “It’s waiting for you to answer.”

“Nobody waits,” says Mr Smith. He eyes the wardrobe sideways, looking for the catch. A hidden button. A second page. Small print. There isn’t one.

He taps Reject all. The wardrobe nods, smiles, and stays exactly where it is. Behind it, the queue turns round in single file and walks off. No fuss.

On a snowy tram platform, a smiling flat-pack wardrobe in a blue T-shirt holds an Allen key and waits politely, while behind it a tidy single-file queue of cookies turns round and walks away. Mr Smith peers out of the crowded tram door, astonished.
It waited for an answer. Then it took it.

“…It’s not getting on.”

“You said no.”

As the doors begin to close, Mr Smith notices a small paper tag hanging from his coat button. He never saw it go on. IKEA. Just us.

“What’s this?”

“So it knows you next time. It doesn’t share it with anyone. It’ll stay a year.”

“A year?”

Yellow shrugs one wing. “Nobody’s perfect.”

The wardrobe waves its Allen key as the tram pulls away. Mr Smith looks at the tag, then at the ten passengers pressed around him. The newspaper turns a page. The nameless one hasn’t blinked.

“Who the bloody hell is that, anyway?”

“I went looking,” says Yellow. “Followed it home. Found a blank page.”

Canary note
It calls itself sdk.ocmthood.com. It isn’t on HuffPost’s list of 118 partners, and it isn’t in the privacy policy. It gave Mr Smith a visitor ID that lasts until 2027, after he’d said no. Its address leads to a blank page, and no company is publicly linked to it. The whole chase, with screenshots, is in the full inquiry →

Mr Smith turns the little IKEA tag over in his fingers. “It asked. It waited. It took no for an answer. Why couldn’t the others do that?”

“Good question,” says Yellow. “Hold on to it.”

Mr Smith gets off at his stop. All ten get off with him.

Part 2 · Tuesday · Ferry

The Finnish Line

Tuesday. The ferry to Helsinki. Grey sea, grey sky. Yellow wears a knitted scarf. Mr Smith has the look of a man with a plan.

“The Finns do it themselves,” he says. “Settings. Switches. No fuss.”

“Seven in ten of them, apparently,” says Yellow, through the scarf.

He blocks third-party cookies. He switches on Do Not Track. Then he writes DO NOT TRACK on a napkin and tapes it to the bench. Arms folded. Very pleased.

Canary note
Blocking third-party cookies and Do Not Track are two browser settings that politely ask sites not to follow you around.

“Fifteen seconds. Two clicks. Let them try now.”

He opens the news. Up the gangway trot the same seven. At the top stands the newspaper, like a tour guide, handing each one a little name badge: HUFFPOST. Mr Smith blinks. He’s been doing it all week. Nobody noticed.

“Those aren’t HuffPost!”

“On paper, they are. HuffPost lets them in under its own name. Your block only stops strangers.”

The velvet suit sits down on the napkin. Crinkle.

“Lovely,” says Yellow. “Now it’s a cushion.”

On a grey ferry deck, the velvet-suited cookie sits smugly on a paper napkin that says DO NOT TRACK, while Mr Smith stares in disbelief and Yellow, in a tiny knitted scarf, looks on deadpan. Far off in the mist, a huge Finnish dragon shakes its head.
Do Not Track. Now a cushion.

“It says Do Not Track!”

“It does. Politely. Nobody reads it.”

Nobody gets off.

Lanyard man strolls out of the ferry café, coffee in hand, and takes his seat. Like clockwork. Far off in the mist, something enormous and Finnish lets out a single, weary puff of flame, and goes back to guarding its own servers.

Part 3 · Wednesday · Bus

Help Yourself

Wednesday. The bus out to IKEA. For the hot dogs. Mr Smith holds up two shiny new helpers like trophies.

“Extensions. They do it for you.”

Yellow’s eyes narrow. “Let’s meet them.”

The first slouches aboard, hands in pockets, in a T-shirt that says I STILL DON’T CARE. Banners simply vanish. Does exactly what it says on the T-shirt.

“Oh, I like him.”

Yellow looks at the T-shirt. Then at Mr Smith. Then back at the T-shirt. “He didn’t say no for you. He just pressed whatever made it go away.”

The same eight climb on anyway. The velvet suit tips his hat.

Nobody gets off.

The second arrives in a crisp white lab coat, clipboard held high, ready to say no properly.

Canary note
This one is Consent-O-Matic: built by privacy researchers in Denmark, to say no for you.

At the news stop and the recipe stop, the aisle is so packed he gets wedged in the doors, arms flailing, and bumped back out onto the pavement. Twice.

A neat little figure in a crisp white lab coat, clipboard held high, is wedged in the doors of a packed bus, arms flailing, while a slouching figure in an I STILL DON’T CARE T-shirt lounges inside. Mr Smith and Yellow watch from their seat.
Brilliant. Just not where it matters.

“He’s stuck!”

“He’s brilliant. Just not where it matters.”

At the government stop and the IKEA stop, nobody’s in the way. He strolls in, ticks every box to no, and sits down neatly, knees together.

Then the recipe site again. The lazy one shrugs, the banner disappears, nobody answers it. And lanyard man… never turns up.

“Where’s lanyard man?”

“He only comes in once someone answers. Nobody did.”

“So the lazy one won.”

“By accident.”

“Still counts,” says Mr Smith, smugly.

“It really doesn’t,” says Yellow, without even turning her head.

Part 4 · Friday · Tram

The Mane Event

Friday. Same tram. Mr Smith has a new browser: Brave. A little lion on the icon. He hasn’t changed a single setting.

“Out of the box?” asks Yellow.

“Out of the box. I’m done fiddling.”

He opens the news. The platform fills up, as usual. Then a lion in a conductor’s cap swings onto the tram, ticket punch in paw.

“Tickets.”

The velvet suit pats his pockets. Then pats them again. His too-wide smile slowly shrinks to a very small one. The lion takes him by the collar and turfs him out onto the platform. Then the next. And the next. Thirteen in all, the nameless one last, still not blinking.

“Thirteen?” says Mr Smith. “I only counted eight.”

“Some were hiding,” says Yellow. “I couldn’t find them either.”

Everybody gets off.

A lion in a conductor’s cap, ticket punch in paw, lifts the velvet-suited cookie by the collar and drops him off the tram, while a line of other trackers is marched out behind him. Mr Smith sits with his feet up, delighted. Yellow looks unimpressed.
Tickets, please.

Only the newspaper in the trench coat stays, clutching his notepad to his chest. His pages droop. He looks very much like yesterday’s news.

“Him too!”

The lion checks his ticket. “He’s the news site itself. I only throw out the outsiders.”

The lion hands him a little note: Please don’t sell or share my data. The newspaper reads it, rolls himself a little tighter, and stuffs it deep in his trench coat with a sniff. Then back to his notepad, scribbling much harder than before.

Canary note
The note is called Global Privacy Control. Brave sends it to every site, automatically.

The recipe site. Seven more get the lion’s paw, most of them hiding behind the magazine. The magazine stays, sulking behind her sunglasses. She gets a note too. Without so much as a glance, she drops it into her handbag, among the cookies. Lanyard man doesn’t even get on.

The IKEA stop. The wardrobe is waiting, its tidy queue of cookies lined up behind it. The lion hands it the same note. The wardrobe reads it, nods, and writes on its clipboard: No, thank you. Noted.

The wardrobe glances back at its queue and gives a small nod. They turn round in single file and go home. Nobody has to be thrown off.

“What was that?”

“Your browser sent everyone the same note,” says Yellow. “The wardrobe read it and wrote your no down.”

“And the others?”

“Got exactly the same note. Ignored it. So the lion threw their crumbly little arses off the tram instead.”

Mr Smith stretches out. Room to breathe, at last. He puts his feet up on the empty seat opposite.

He punches the air. Then, because for once he isn’t packed in like a sardine, he punches it again. “I’ve solved it.” A week of banners. One napkin. Two helpers. A ferry to Finland and far too many evenings reading about what the Finns do. “I have actually solved it.”

“The lion solved it,” says Yellow, not looking up. She’s reading the front page of the newspaper across the aisle: a little testing script on some very big news sites has started picking people’s pockets. Her eyes narrow. Somewhere in that small yellow head, the next trip is already being booked.

“I downloaded the lion,” says Mr Smith, still glowing. “Teamwork.”

Yellow drags her eyes away from the front page. She looks at him for a long moment. Then she gives him one slow, solemn pat on the head with her wing, and goes back to her reading.

The lion tips its cap and swings off at the next stop. Yellow watches it go.

Padlock door

04 The Open Door · The takeaway

He said no all week. Two sites listened. A lion did the rest.

Yellow turns back to Mr Smith. “That lion had a bad patch once. 2020. Slipped its own little codes into people’s web addresses. Got caught. Sad story. Said sorry.”

“And?”

“And today it threw thirteen strangers off your tram before you’d even seen a banner.”

“So…?”

Yellow settles her feathers. “So… second chance? Bit of an ask. You’re meant to get your principles right first time. But it’s there, if you fancy giving it a go.”

Half onion

+1 One more layer · Saturday

Saturday. His last day. One more trip out to IKEA. A hot dog for the road.

Mr Smith sits down in the restaurant, hot dog in one hand, and opens his phone to check the news.

Chrome. Out of habit.

A man in a burgundy velvet suit slides into the seat opposite. A nod. A raised eyebrow. Neither of them says a word.

Yellow lets out a very small sigh.

Over at the serving counter, a queue is forming. A rolled-up newspaper with a notepad. Six familiar faces. And one with no face.

The assistant leans over the till. “Onions with that?”

Yellow holds her breath. Her cheeks puff. Her feathers puff. She goes very, very round.

“HOLD. THE. ONION.”

In the IKEA restaurant, Mr Smith sits with a hot dog and his phone. Opposite him, the velvet-suited cookie raises an eyebrow. On his shoulder, Yellow is puffed up perfectly round, cheeks bulging. A familiar queue of trackers waits at the counter.
Old habits.
Microphone

05 The Song · Over to you

Over to you

What’s your verdict?

When a cookie banner pops up, do you hit Reject all?

Tap an answer to vote. Anonymous, no cookies.

One tap, no cookies, no account. Then see how everyone else voted.

See every verdict →
The Dossier

The tools Mr Smith tried

  • Consent-O-Matic: consentomatic.au.dk
    The free extension from Aarhus University that answers cookie banners for you.
  • Brave: brave.com
    The browser with the lion. Blocks trackers out of the box.
  • Global Privacy Control: globalprivacycontrol.org
    The “please don’t sell or share my data” note, and which browsers send it.

The rules

Want to go deeper? Every banner, every cookie count and every screenshot is in the full inquiry: The Reject All Button Is Lying to You →

Community Dispatch

The Commentary

If you could throw one tracker off your tram, who’d go first?

Answer the question, share a story, or just tell me what you thought.
Zero cookies, no accounts, no tracking.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *